Wednesday 17 May 2023

SPFBO 9, Phase 1




This page charted progress in Phase 1 of the 9th Self-Published Fantasy Blog-Off, which ran from June 1st to October 30th 2023. To read more about the SPFBO contest please visit the homepage.









Here are some factoids about this year's entries:
(taken from this list very helpfully compiled by C. Borden)

2 have 1,000+ ratings on Goodreads
30 have 100+ ratings on Goodreads
56 have 50+ ratings on Goodreads

Wild Knight has 6,080 ratings on Goodreads.






Here are the 6 oldest entries - A Donkey, A Stablehand And An Empire was published 15 years ago.






Here are the 6 longest entries - Through Dreams So Dark has 892 pages.


Updates!

Lynn's Books and The Critiquing Chemist reveal our final finalist!
A Rival Most Vial is reviewed on Lynn's Books.
Fantasy-Faction choose our ninth finalist!
Before We Go Blog choose our eighth finalist!
Hills of Heather and Bone is reviewed on Fantasy-Faction.
Fantasy-Faction find another semi-finalist.
The Many Shades of Midnight is reviewed on Lynn's Books.
Lynn's Books reviews Under The Lesser Moon.
Credible Threats is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Before We Go Blog reviews The Briar Crown.
Four cuts and a semi-finalist from Fantasy-Faction.
Before We Go Blog reviews Trial of the Alchemist.
Jagged Emerald City is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
A Tree's Heart is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Philip Chase chooses our 7th finalist!
Twilight Kingdom is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Before We Go Blog reviews The Bachelor's Valet.
Of Deeds Most Valiant is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Before We Go Blog reviews The Undead Sorceress.
The Way Of Renegades is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Before We Go Blog reviews Written In Water.
Infernal Shadows is review on Before We Go Blog.
Queen's Book Asylum choose our 6th finalist!
The Betrayer is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Queen's Book Asylum reviews The Last Fang Of God.
Four more fall on Fantasy-Faction, plus another semi-finalist.
Philip Chase brings us his 4th semi-finalist.
Eleventh Cycle is reviewed on Queen's Book Asylum.
Before We Go Blog reviews The Third Crossing.
A Dagger In The Winds is reviewed on Queen's Book Asylum.
Before We Go Blog reviews The First Rule.
Under the Lesser Moon is reviewed on The Critiquing Chemist.
Before We Go Blog reviews Sisters of Jade.
Cuts and semi-finalists from the Critiquing Chemist.
Before We Go Blog reviews Truth of Crowns.
Our 5th finalist is declared on Fantasy Book Critic!
Queen's Book Asylum reviews Scarlet and Sunder.
Our 4th finalist is declared by Bookborn!
Fae Gods: Maze is reviewed on Queen's Book Asylum.
Team Bookborn's last semi-finalist announced.
Semi-finalists announced on Lynn's Books.
Lynn's Books reviews Dream of Death City.
Our 3rd finalist is declared by Becky M!
Vanishing Ink is reviewed bt the Critiquing Chemist (Lynn's Books)
Lynn's Books reviews Twicetime.
The Heron Kings Rampant is reviewed by Lynn's Books.
Lynn's Books reviews The First And Last Demon.
Five eliminations from the Critiquing Chemist (Lynn's Books).
Becky M makes her final cuts.
Lynn's Books reviews The Bone Spear.
Our 2nd finalist is declared on The Weatherwax Report!
Before We Go Blog reviews Cold West.
Semi-finalist, Deceit, is reviewed on Queen's Book Asylum.
4 more cuts from Becky M.
The Weatherwax Reports on her last book - The Ghosts in the Flames.
Dark Innocence is reviewed by Lynn's Books.
The Weatherwax Report reviews Atenia.
Candle Children is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Lynn's Books reviews Of Thieves And Shadows.
Through Dreams So Dark is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
The Weatherwax Report reports on Night Demon.
A Wreck of Witches is reviewed on team Bookborn.
Necrotown is review by team Bookborn,
Philip Chase choses his 2nd semi-finalist.
The Weatherwax Report reviews The Dark Heart of Redemption.
The Unchosen is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
The Dark Heart of Redemption is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
The Weatherwax Report has a review for Darkwind.
For Evergreens and Aspen Trees is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
Queen's Book Asylum chose their last semi-finalist.
Many Savage Moons is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
Becky M reviews Sul.
The Esmachine reviews Daughters of Tith on The Weatherwax Report.
Four cuts from Lynn's Books.
The Weatherwax Report rolls on with another semi-finalist.
Wild Knight is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
Before We Go Blog reviews Trial of the Alchemist.
A new semi-finalist from The Weatherwax Report.
The Weatherwax Report reports on Seeds of War.
Mrs Covington's is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
The Weatherwax Report reviews Watchers of the Evenfall.
Another semi-finalist from the Weatherwax Report team.
Before We Go Blog reviews The Liar Charms.
A semi-finalist is announced on Before We Go Blog.
Covers With Cassidy picks the first finalist!
A semi-finalist is chosen on The Weatherwax Report.
The Weatherwax Report reviews The Certainty of Blood.
 A semi-finalist is chosen on Queen's Book Asylum.
The Weatherwax Report reviews The Beauty of Dawn.
The Wickwire Watch is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
Lynn's Books cuts another 4 titles.
Another semi-finalist is picked on Team Bookborn.
Team Covers With Cassidy chooses another semi-finalist.
Echoes of Dragons is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
A new semi-finalist is chosen on Queen's Book Asylum.
Becky M reviews The Dragon's Hide.
A 4th semi-finalist is chosen by Fantasy Book Critic.
The Werewold of Whitechapel is reviewed by Team Weatherwax.
Team Bookborn reviews To Steal The Sun.
Three cuts from Becky M.
First cuts from  Lynn's Books and The Critiquing Chemist.
Queen's Book Asylum make a semi-finalist announcement.
Another semi-finalist from team Covers With Cassidy.
Fantasy-Faction make five cuts.
The Fall Is All There Is is revewed by Becky M.
Before We Go Blog reviews Heliotrope
Light Above is reviewed by Team Bookborn.
Team Fantasy Book Critic another semi-finalist is chosen.
Kill Your Darlings is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
Queen's Book Asylum reveal a semi-finalist.
A Quiet Vengeance is reviewed by the Weatherwax Report team.
The Weatherwax Report reviews A Magical Imperative.
Another semi-finalist is chosen by the Covers With Cassidy team.
Team Bookborn review Nascent Witch.
A semi-finalist is chosen by the Covers With Cassidy team.
Becky M swings her axe - three cuts.
Three cuts from the Weatherwax Team.
Team Bookborn review Strangers in the High City,
Two more cuts on Queen's Book Asylum.
Philip Chase chooses his first semi-finalist.
The Covers With Cassidy team review Spell Fade.
Vevin Song is reviewed on The Weatherwax Report.
The Weatherwax Report reviews Chimera.
Queen's Book Asylum cuts three more titles.
Three cuts on Queen's Book Asylum.
Unfamiliar Territory is reviewed by Team Bookborn.
Becky M reviews Mordicax.
Danu's Curse is revewed on Before We Go Blog.
Before We Go Blog reviews Humanborn.
Three cuts from Becky M.
Team Bookborn review The Fey of Castle Garden.
Two more cuts from Queen's Book Asylum.
Becky M reviews Angel From The Rust.
Blood Will Out is reviewed on Covers With Cassidy.
Before We Go Blog reviews Shadow of a Winter Moon.
Cuts and more from Fantasy Book Critic.
Two cuts on Queen's Book Asylum.
Team Bookborn review Askefise.
 A semi-finalist is chosen by The Covers With Cassidy team.
The Covers With Cassidy team have a review for The Awakening Fire.
Three cuts on Becky M.
The Book of Zog is reviewed by Becky M.
Queen's Book Asylum announce cuts and a semi-finalist.
The Covers With Cassidy team review Mambo Wizard: Breakfast Is Served.
Team Bookborn review The Winds of Change.
Dream of the Sphere is reviewed by Becky M.
Deathbringer is reviewed by Team Bookborn.
The Weatherwax Report reviews The Lady Jewel Diviner.
Wild Eyed Southern Boys is reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
Becky M reviews Doll Girl Meets Dead Guy.
Five books reviewed by the Covers With Cassidy team.
The Covers With Cassidy team have a review for Bioshifter.
The Last of Dai'akan is reviewed by The Weatherwax Report.
Team Bookborn review Daughter of the Beast.
Edgar and the Flyboys is reviewed on Team Bookborn.
On Team Bookborn A Thing Immortal is reviewed.
The Way of Unity is this year's first semi-finalist - reviewed on Before We Go Blog.
The Weatherwax Report reviews The Bleeding Stone.
The Weatherwax Report kicks things off with a review of Feast!


10 books are still in the running!

We have 56 semi-finalists.

We have 10 finalists.


Red is cut

+ (& bolding) indicates semi-finalist

Green for the finalists.


Fantasy-Faction

Kenny Gould

The Castle of 1,000 Doors

Michael Webb

Fortress of the Lost Amulet

Sadir S. Samir

The Crew +

Casey White

Roots and Steel

Mike Mollman

Becoming A Druid

E.M. McConnell

The Sunset Sovereign

Ashley Capes

The Moss Dragon of Brittlekeep

Michael R. Schultheiss

The Altar of My Fate

Chris Mayne

Heretic

Paul Mouchet

Between Land and Sea: A Little Mermaid Retelling

William Ray

Shadow Debt

Aldrea Alien

Tracking Trouble

C.N. Rowan

imPerfect Magic +

K.E.Andrews

Hills of Heather and Bone +

Yuval Kordov

The Hand of God

Joshua Scott Edwards

An Ocean of Others +

CL Jarvis

The Doctrines of Fire

J.L.Mullins

Mageling

R.S Ford

Herald of the Storm

Michael Roberti

The Traitors We Are

C M Kerley

The Hummingbird's Tear

Victoria Tecken

Phased

Raina Nightingale

Heart of Fire

Becky James

The Tenets in the Tattoos

Sean Gibson

The Camelot Shadow

Laurie Janey

The Crossing

Samuel Hinton

Soul Relic

J. E. Purrazzi

The Legend of Tawhiri

Benjamin Aeveryn

Salt in the Wound +

Phil Williams

Dyer Street Punk Witches +


Fantasy Book Critic

Jessica A. McMinn

The Ruptured Sky +

A. R. Witham

The Legend of Black Jack

Alex Hanson

The Heart of Jesparia

Oliver Carman

Out of Shadows

H.D. Woolf

Red Mage

Lyra Wolf

That Good Mischief

Grace Bridges

Volcano City

Luis Falcao de Magalhaes

The Daughter of the Ice

Aaron Jackson

The Cataclysm

James Mordechai

A Crack in the World

Daan Katz

Night's Reign

Ben Green

Forged in the Fallout

Heidi K. Allen

Where Madness Lies

Tracy M Joyce

Rada

Jamie Jackson

The Sparrow and the Oak Tree +

Melissa Polk

Beautiful Undone

David Heyman

A Donkey, A Stablehand & An Empire

Mitchell Hogan

Crucible of Lies +

Jack Batchen

The Outside

RJ Wheldrake

That Which The Deep Heart Knows

J.C. Snow

The Phoenix and the Sword

H.C. Newell

Curse of the Fallen

Taylor Hartley

A Gallery for the Barbarian +

Todd Herzman

Hack, Slash & Burn

Sam Pigg

Revolution

J.D.L. Rosell

The Last Ranger +

Katherine D. Graham

The Vow That Twisted Fate

M. X. Walker

The Girl And Her Demon

Chad Retterath

Notes on Monster Hunting

Emma L. Adams

Death's Disciple +


Lynn's Books + The Critiquing Chemist

Alexander Layne

The Bone Spear

Cassandra Stirling

The Deep Space Between

Felix Taylor

Crown of Rebellion

Steve Hugh Westenra

The Wings of Ashtaroth

Lincoln Law

A Crown of Blood

Eric Lewis

The Heron Kings Rampant

PJ Nwosu

Dream of Death City +

W.R. Gingell

A Whisker Behind

Andrew D Meredith

Deathless Beast

Hiyodori

The First and Last Demon +

Jay Tallsquall

Legacy of the Vermillion Blade

Brien Feathers

Warlock of Muscovy

Maxime Jaz

Khirion

R.K. Ashwick

A Rival Most Vial: Potioneering for Love and Profit +

PJ Alexander

Dark Innocence

James Lloyd Dulin

No Heart for a Thief

B. S. H. Garcia

Of Thieves and Shadows

C M Debell

The Many Shades of Midnight +

K.B. Sprague

Out of the Grey

Joe Coates

The Darkness Calling

Michelle Piper

Price of Innocence

Alex Robins

Panacea

Carol Carman

Twicetime +

Shelly Campbell

Under The Lesser Moon +

Zachary M. Kekac

The Wayfarer

JC Rycroft

The Blood-Born Dragon

Reed Logan Westgate

Soulstealer Origins

B. N. Reele

Vanishing Ink

C. E. Page

A Song of Sorrow

Simone Snaith

The Quavering Air


The Weatherwax Report

Sienna Frost

Awakening

A. L. Lorensen

For Evergreens and Aspen Trees

j.e. pittman

Felix Chance

Tim Hardie

A Quiet Vengeance

Stuart Simms

Feast +

Jay Requard

Atenia

R. Dugan

Darkwind

W.D Seitz

The Beauty of Dawn

João F. Silva

Seeds of War

Joseph John Lee

The Bleeding Stone +

Ben Spencer

Many Savage Moons

Suzannah Rowntree

The Werewolf of Whitechapel +

Annabel Chase

Wild Knight

Rosalie Oaks

The Lady Jewel Diviner

J. Patricia Anderson

Daughters of Tith

Jeremy Miller

The Last Dai'akan +

L.E. Harper

Kill Your Darlings

Tim Frankovich

The Certainty of Blood

Thomas Allen

Chimera

Jonathan Neves Mayers

Vevin Song

C. Borden

Echoes of Dragons

Laura Huie

The Unchosen

Seann Barbour

The Ghosts in the Flames

Joe Field

Watchers of the Evenfall

Stephen Wolberius

Night Demon

Gerard Howard

The Fractured God

Jacquelyn Hagen

The Wickwire Watch +

Edith Pawlicki

A Magical Imperative

Darran M Handshaw

The Dark Heart of Redemption

Em McDermott

The Woods


Becky M

Shan Syed

Western Invasion

Lidiya Foxglove

Doll Girl Meets Dead Guy

Jay S. Willis

Dream of the Sphere

Alec Hutson

The Book of Zog +

Jeff McIntyre

The Garden Gnome

R.L. Parker

Siscci

Peter Benton

Eve's Apple

Jason Link

Angel from the Rust

A.R. Rathmann

Gates to Illvelion

Mark McKerracher

Mordicax

Niranjana Siva and Archana Sujai

The Missing Piece of History

C.M. Caplan

The Fall Is All There Is +

Richard Fierce

Throne of Deceit

Chaz Lebel

Litany of the Destroyer

Dustin Porta and D.K. Holmberg

The Dragon's Hide +

Charlotte E. English

Gloaming

Jill Chard

The Relic Thief

T. R. Peers

The Zero of Destiny

Jacqui Davis, Katy Grierson

Sul +

Simon Graeme

Dark Lament

Francis Deer and Mika Hunter

Stars and Ravens

Samuel Gately

The Rise of the Falsemarked

E.L. Lyons

Starlight Jewel

Colm Quinn

Bluebell

Joan Marie Verba

Twelve

Wilbur Seymore

Young Wytch

Anne Mattias

Kingsrise

J. W. Judge

Casual Business with Fairies

J.D. Mitchell

Springtide Harvest

Gregory Kontaxis

The Return of the Knights


Before We Go Blog

Elizabeth Schechter

Written in Water

Steven William Hannah

The First Rule

Tayor Crook

Infernal Shadow

Delilah Waan

Petition +

Sarah K. Balstrup

The Way of Unity +

Sarah K. L. Wilson

Of Deeds Most Valiant

Lorain O'Neil

The Liar Charms

Angelika Rust

A Tree's Heart

Carl D. Albert

Truth of Crowns

JF Garrard

The Undead Sorceress

Hannah E. Carey

The Betrayer

Joanna Maciejewska

Humanborn

Clayton Snyder

Cold West +

Angela Boord

Through Dreams So Dark

HJ Tolson

Twilight Kingdom

Michael Gisman

Defenders of Myth: Beginnings

Shawn McGee

Wild Eyed Southern Boys

Daniel Meyer

Credible Threats +

James Downe

Sisters of Jade

Cam Sinclair

Shadow of the Winter Moon

Nicole Pierman

Danu's Curse

Karim Soliman

The Third Crossing

Steve D. Wall

The Way of Renegades

Helen Rygh-Pedersen

The Briar Crown +

Michael Baker

Candle Children

K.R.R. Lockhaven

Mrs. Covington's

Arden Powell

The Bachelor's Valet +

Palmer Pickering

Heliotrope +

Trevor Melanson

Trial of the Alchemist +

R. K. Brainerd

Jagged Emerald City


Queen's Book Asylum

Kian N. Ardalan

Eleventh Cycle +

Ted Cross

The Shattered Spire

Kate Schumacher

Shadow of Fire

Timothy Wolff

Platinum Tinted Darkness

Mike Rousseau

Scarlet and Sunder +

Philinna Wood

Fae Gods: Maze +

R. R. Hunter

The Untold Prophecy

Jean Gill

The Ring Breaker

M.T. Fontaine

Carved Amidst the Shadows

C. Litka

Beneath the Lanterns

Aaron Bunce and Christopher Guhl

Wings of the Storm

Melissa Wright

Beyond the Filigree Wall

L. James Rice

The Contessa of Mostul Ûbar

Melissa Stone

Path of the Warrior

Brendan Noble

A Dagger in the Winds +

Christiane Knight

In Sleep You Know

Sharon Rivest

Deceit +

Aisha Urooj

The Stone Mermaid

Susan Maxwell

And the Wildness

Peter Mooren

The Return of Abaddon

Frank Borrelli

Reign of Extinction

Drew Montgomery

Gods of the Deep

Ryan Kirk

The Last Fang of God +

Sarah Cline

The Gardens of Ash

John Champaign

Endless Seas

Catherine M Walker

Unwanted

M.C. Burnell

The Spider's Friend

Brogan Thomas

Rebel Unicorn

Bogdan Tăbușcă

Rise of the Empress

Jayme Hunt

Marked by Fate


Bookborn

Derek Alan Siddoway & Katie Cross

A Spring for Spears

Matthew Zorich

Bastards of Liberty

A.E. Dinsmoor

Battle for Neverland: Countdown

Daniel Maidman

The Exile of Zanzibar +

V. A. Boston

Fairy Door

E C Greaves

Daughter of the Beast +

Kevin Wright

Terminus Rex

J.E. Cabrera

Strangers in the High City

Melissa Bobe

Nascent Witch

Barry K Gregory

A Thing Immortal

Michael Michel

The Price of Power +

SC Gowland

Delusions & Dragons

Brian O'Sullivan

Liath Luachra: The Raiders

Lily Anne Crow

If Light Above +

Belinda Crawford

Demons & Battleskirts Volume 1

Abigail Morrison

The Yochni's Eye

Troy Knowlton

The Winds of Change

Louise Gorday

Edgar and the Flyboys

Kristin L Hamblin

Fated Born

Nia Quinn

A Wreck of Witches

Freya Faust

Stray Dogs

Alexander Nader

Necrotown +

Eileen Mueller

Anakisha's Dragon

Blake Carpenter

Deathbringer

Mathilda Zeller

The Revenge of Bridget Cleary

Dan Fitzgerald

The Living Waters

Naomi P. Cohen

The Fey of Castle Garden

R. Lindsay Carter

Unfamiliar Territory

S. M. Carter

To Steal the Sun

Rebecca Schmid

Askefise


Philip Chase

Austin Windsor

A Twist of Fate

Alice Johnson

Little Secrets

Norbert Zsivicz

Sealed Empire

Mandy Burkhead

A Single Spark

Audrey Martin

A Searing Faith

M. V. Prindle

Bob the Wizard +

Lisa Vandiver

Mystic Mist

Alex Raizman

The Dungeon that Walks Like a Man

Angel Haze

Blood of Vengeance

Thomas Howard Riley

The Monsters We Feed

Natalie Kelda

River in the Galaxy

Mitriel Faywood

A Gamble of Gods +

M. H. Thaung

The Diamond Device

Amanda Muratoff & Kayla Hansen

Embrace of the Shade

IQ Malcolm

Church of Thieves +

Steven Paul Watson

Fairywood Falls

Daniel J. Lyons

The Path to Vihaan

Toby Bennett

A Lady in Crystal

Thomas J. Prestopnik

Nicholas Raven and the Wizards' Web

Rose Catherine Khan

Return to the Castle

Mandy O'Dell

Witch Stone

Melinda Kucsera

Curse Breaker Enchanted

Marcus Lee

The Mountain of Souls

Morgan Shank

A Low Country

Juliet Vane

Tales of Sand and Stars

Amber L. Werner

Shadows That Bind Us +

Brock Mays

Embers

Morgan Stang

Murder at Spindle Manor +

W.D. Kilpack III

Crown Prince

Bryan Asher

The Fear of Moncroix


CoversWithCassidy

J. Daniel Layfield

Spell Fade

Adam Copeland

Echoes of Avalon

Rob J. Hayes

Pawn's Gambit +

Lara Lynwood

Blood Will Out

Wend Raven

Master of the Void +

Seth Hobbs

A Sword of the Three Rivers

Mary McKenna

Lady of Ravensmere

Jamie Edmundson

An Inheritance of Ash and Blood

NC Koussis

The Sword of Mercy and Wrath +

Michael J. Hedayat

Grace Defend Us

D. N. Bryn

Odder Still

Giordano J. Lahaderne

The Mambo Wizard: Breakfast is Served!

N.R. Gravel

Opanumbra

Natalie Maher

Bioshifter

Alexander Wyatt

The Fires of Time +

Debbie Iancu-Haddad

Speechless in Achten Tan

Cassie Greutman

Regeneration

Oliver Laws

Crystal Gunslinger - The Obsidian Outlaws

RavensDagger

Love Crafted

Zack Bel

The Nightingale Prince

Olena Nikitin

Autumn Chaos

Meredith Hart

Hearts Lost

Cassidy Faline

The Awakening Fire

C. D. McKenna

The Blood of the Lion +

MT Zimny

Beta

Nathan Hartle

Summoning and Sacrifice

A.J. Cerna

City of Mages

M. H. Woodscourt

Prince of the Fallen

Aaron Hodges

Darkstrider

Nancy Foster

Fragmented Fates







First 300 entries above







11 comments:

  1. Engines of Alchemancy by Scott Marlowe was formerly The Five Elements (according to Amazon), which was entered in the first SPFBO.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Between Land and Sea: A Little Mermaid Retelling is in two places, so one of them should get a replacement

    ReplyDelete
  3. The link to "Blood Will Out" is not working. The review is still up on the blog site though if you navigate to the homepage.

    ReplyDelete
  4. You skipped The Woods review by Weatherwax.

    ReplyDelete
  5. As a recently self published author, I'm A) lamenting that I published just a little to late to participate in SPFBO 9, and B) Quite worried about how I will find out about SPFBO 10 early enough to ensure that I am able to get considered. From the sound of it, the fill up time means I will have to know exactly what info to send and be ready to send it at exactly the right time... How do I improve my chances of being aware and having the proper info on hand so I can sign up fast enough? I've of course followed this blog, but I worry that I'll miss the email among other things I follow... especially since it took less than 1hour... What timezone will the entry acceptance date be focused on?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It is announced we’ll in advance with time zone specified.

      Delete
  6. Looks like the review for Defenders of Myth from Before We Go Blog is missing: https://beforewegoblog.com/spfbo9-defenders-of-myth-beginnings-by-michael-gisman/

    ReplyDelete
  7. An info reg. the longest book: That should be "Wings of Ashtaroth" by Steve Hugh Westenra (1005 pages): https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/156966791-the-wings-of-ashtaroth

    ReplyDelete
  8. Can cuts and finalists not be in red and green? Some of us mere mortals are red-green colour deficient!

    ReplyDelete